The American Samoa NIL Advantage: Why U.S. National Status Changes the Game

Rock Report · October 19, 2026
By Red Envelope Sports Football Business
Roughly 25,000 international athletes compete in the NCAA, and almost all of them hold F-1 student visas, according to a September 2026 analysis by the law firm Parker Poe. For those athletes, the second season of the House settlement era has made one thing clear. Immigration law, not the NCAA rulebook, sets the outer limit on how much they can earn from their name, image and likeness while they are in the United States.
Players born in American Samoa start from a different place. Under federal law they are U.S. nationals, not foreign students, so the F-1 work restrictions that hold back teammates from independent Samoa, Tonga, Fiji, New Zealand or Australia do not apply to them. For families on the island weighing college football, that difference is worth understanding before the first NIL offer arrives.
Who Counts as a U.S. National
People born in American Samoa, including Swains Island, are generally U.S. nationals at birth under Section 308 of the Immigration and Nationality Act. They are not U.S. citizens, according to U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services. The State Department notes that every citizen is a national, but only a small group of people hold U.S. nationality without citizenship. Their U.S. passports carry an endorsement stating that the bearer is a U.S. national and not a U.S. citizen.
The key word is born. Living in American Samoa does not by itself make someone a U.S. national. Many families on the island hold citizenship from independent Samoa, Tonga or another country, and a player born in Apia or Nukuʻalofa who grew up in Pago Pago is generally not a U.S. national. Federal law does extend national status to certain children born abroad to U.S. national parents, but only if the parents meet specific residence or physical-presence requirements. Families who are unsure should confirm a player’s status with official documents before planning around it.
Why the F-1 Limits Matter So Much
A student on an F-1 visa may work only in narrow categories the federal government authorizes, such as limited on-campus jobs or training directly tied to a major. Commercial NIL work like sponsored posts, paid appearances, camps and endorsements does not fit any of them, Parker Poe explains. Schools such as the University of Florida warn that NIL activity done in the U.S. while in F-1 status would likely violate immigration law.
The safer routes for F-1 athletes are narrow. Genuinely passive income, such as royalties from a group licensing deal, and NIL work performed entirely outside the U.S. are generally treated as lower risk. School revenue-sharing payments under the House settlement are the hardest question. As of September 2026, Parker Poe reported that there was no controlling guidance from the Department of Homeland Security, USCIS or Congress on whether F-1 athletes can accept those payments. Some schools treat them as licensing royalties, according to We Are NIL, while others warn that performance-based bonuses make them look like wages.
Some advisors point to work visas such as the P-1A athlete classification or the O-1 extraordinary-ability visa as alternatives. Both require a petition and must meet strict standards, and neither is a routine path for a typical college football player. An F-1 athlete considering one should work with an immigration attorney.
What U.S. National Status Changes
U.S. nationals do not need a student visa to attend a U.S. college. The State Department’s student visa rules apply to foreign nationals, and an athlete born in American Samoa is not one. USCIS states that citizens and noncitizen nationals are both automatically eligible for employment in the U.S. They still complete Form I-9 like any other worker, selecting “noncitizen national of the United States”, and may present the same documents as U.S. citizens, such as a U.S. passport.
In practical terms, an athlete born in American Samoa can generally take the same kinds of NIL opportunities as a teammate from California or Utah, including appearances, camps, sponsored posts and school revenue-share agreements, without the immigration risk an F-1 teammate faces. That status also helps with paying for school. Students born in American Samoa are U.S. nationals for purposes of federal student aid, so they can file the FAFSA and may qualify for federal grants and loans if they meet the other requirements.
The advantage over other U.S. territories is a different story. Players from Guam, the Northern Mariana Islands, Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands are generally U.S. citizens and also don’t need F-1 visas. The meaningful contrast is with recruits from the independent Pacific nations, who must come to the U.S. on student visas. Even athletes from New Zealand and Australia, which are Visa Waiver Program countries, cannot use that program to study.
What Still Applies
U.S. national status removes an immigration barrier. It does not remove the rest of the rulebook, and families should plan for each of these:
- NCAA eligibility. Athletes still need to register with the NCAA Eligibility Center and meet the academic and amateurism standards for their division.
- NIL Go disclosure. Division I athletes must report third-party NIL deals worth $600 or more through NIL Go, as the Rock Report covered in Issue 012. School policies and state laws can add their own requirements.
- Taxes. NIL income is taxable. The IRS explains in Publication 570 how American Samoa residency affects filing, and income earned for work done in the States generally cannot be excluded from U.S. tax. Earlier Rock Report pieces on 1099s and paying taxes on NIL income are a good starting point. Families with ties to both American Samoa and a U.S. state should talk to a tax professional.
- Contracts. Revenue-share agreements and NIL deals are binding business documents. Having a qualified representative review them before signing matters just as much for a U.S. national as for anyone else.
Practical Takeaways for Families
Confirm status early. Keep a birth certificate and a U.S. passport for any player born in American Samoa, so coaches, compliance offices and employers can verify nationality without delays. If a player was born somewhere else, find out early whether he will need an F-1 visa.
Tell schools up front. Some recruiting and compliance staff may not be familiar with noncitizen national status. Make clear early that the athlete is a U.S. national and does not need an I-20, so he isn’t routed into international-student paperwork he doesn’t need.
Use the advantage responsibly. Being able to accept NIL work is an opportunity, not a guarantee of income. The same disciplines apply as for any athlete: report deals, set money aside for taxes, and have every contract reviewed before signing. For families evaluating offers, a representative who understands both the business side and the island context can help turn that advantage into a plan.
More REPORTS From The Rock
