From The Rock
|
November 2, 2026

NIL Go Has Turned Down $156.9 Million in Deals: What Collective Offers Must Prove

A coastal landscape with steep, green, forested mountains and triangular rock formations near the shoreline under a gray, overcast sky.

Rock Report · November 2, 2026

By Red Envelope Sports · Football Business

The College Sports Commission, the group that enforces the House settlement’s pay rules, has now ruled on more than 48,000 third-party NIL deals through its NIL Go system. In its Sept. 9 data report, the CSC said it had cleared 46,478 deals worth $582.49 million since NIL Go launched in June 2025. It had not cleared 2,296 deals worth $156.93 million.

The money that doesn’t clear tends to be big money. In July and August 2026, the CSC cleared 12,283 deals worth $227.25 million and turned down 484 worth $67.08 million. That works out to about $18,500 per cleared deal and about $138,600 per deal not cleared.

For families weighing offers this fall, the key question isn’t only how much. It’s who is paying.

Who Counts as “Associated”

NIL Go treats deals differently when the payer is tied to a school. On its NIL rules page, the CSC says an associated entity includes a group that exists in significant part to support a school’s athletics program or its athletes, or that has helped recruit or retain athletes. That description fits most collectives.

An associated individual includes anyone who works for or owns part of an associated entity, anyone who has helped with recruiting or retention, and anyone who has given more than $50,000 in their lifetime to the school or to an associated entity. That last one covers a lot of big boosters.

Associated deals were 7,089 of the deals cleared in July and August, worth $188.64 million. That’s about 83% of the money cleared in those two months.

The Two Tests

1. Valid business purpose. Under NCAA Bylaw 22.1.3, an associated entity or individual can’t make a deal with or pay a recruit or current player unless it’s “for a valid business purpose related to the promotion or endorsement of goods or services provided to the general public for profit.” The CSC looks at whether the product or service is sold for profit, not whether the collective itself makes money. The deal also has to use the athlete’s NIL “in a clear and specific manner.” Paying for rights with no plan to use them, which the CSC calls “warehousing,” may not pass.

2. Range of compensation. The pay has to be in line with what similarly situated people with comparable NIL value earn. The CSC’s model, built with Deloitte, looks at the deal’s obligations, the athlete’s performance and social media reach, the local market and the school’s market reach.

What Changed July 1

In a June 23 memo, the CSC said that starting July 1, 2026, associated deals worth $600 to $15,000 skip the range-of-compensation review until an athlete passes $50,000 in associated deals in an academic year. Any associated deal over $15,000 is still reviewed. The valid-business-purpose test still applies to every associated deal, at any size.

The CSC’s own example: three associated deals for $10,000, $15,000 and $20,000. Only the $20,000 deal gets the pay review. That puts the athlete at $45,000 for the year, so the next deal gets reviewed if it’s more than $5,000.

The Rules Every Deal Follows

Every Division I athlete has to report third-party NIL deals worth $600 or more in NIL Go within five business days of signing or agreeing to payment terms. We covered the $600 rule in September. If a deal isn’t cleared, the athlete can revise and resubmit it, cancel it and return any payment, or appeal to a neutral arbitrator within 14 days. The CSC warns that going ahead with a deal that wasn’t cleared can cost a player his eligibility.

Enforcement Is Picking Up

In October, CBS Sports reported that the CSC is conducting longer-term investigations of five to 10 Power Four programs over possible cap evasion and NIL violations involving schools, athletes and third parties, according to Sports Business Journal’s summary. No long-term investigation had been completed as of that report. For players, the takeaway is simple: a deal built to get around the rules can put the athlete’s eligibility at risk, not just the school’s.

What Families Should Ask

  • Who is paying? The school through revenue sharing, a collective, a booster or a business with no tie to the school? Each one is reviewed differently.
  • What’s the work? Get the appearances, posts or endorsements spelled out. A deal with no real work is the kind that gets stuck.
  • What happens if it isn’t cleared? Ask whether payment waits on NIL Go clearance, and what happens to money already paid if it’s turned down.
  • Who reports it? The player is responsible for reporting on time, even if a representative enters the deal.
  • Who’s on our side? Have the contract reviewed by someone who works for the family, not the school or the collective.

In our culture, the aiga makes big decisions together. An NIL deal is one of them. Ask the questions before you sign, and get the answers in writing.

← Back to the Rock Report

Become a Sponsor

Want your logo here?

See partnership opportunities

Connect