From The Rock
|
October 19, 2026

Uluave, BYU’s Polynesian Defense Topple No. 2 Notre Dame

A coastal landscape with steep, green, forested mountains and triangular rock formations near the shoreline under a gray, overcast sky.

Rock Report · October 19, 2026

By Keiki Misipeka From The Rock

No. 8 BYU beat No. 2 Notre Dame 28-24 on Saturday night in Provo, the Cougars’ first win over the Irish since 2004 and their first win over a top-10 opponent since 2018. The AP recap called it a thriller that ended Notre Dame’s 16-game winning streak and kept BYU undefeated at 6-0 in front of 65,179 fans, the largest home crowd at LaVell Edwards Stadium since 2004.

The final stop belonged to a defense that looked like the village. Linebacker Cade Uluave, of Tongan descent, led BYU with 9 tackles (6 solo) and 1 tackle for loss, per the ESPN box score. Safety Faletau Satuala, a Polynesian College Player of the Year watch-list player from Bountiful, finished with 5 tackles and 1 pass breakup and made the tackle on Notre Dame’s next-to-last play that put the Irish at the BYU 8. Head coach Kalani Sitake, of Tongan ancestry and a 2025 Polynesian Football Hall of Fame inductee, watched his team hold on when it mattered most.

Overlooked at Home, Built Elsewhere, Then Brought Back

Uluave’s path is the kind of story Polynesian families keep asking about: what happens when the hometown school says no.

BYU did not recruit him out of Mountain Ridge High School in Herriman, Utah. He was a three-star prospect who committed to California, then suffered a serious knee injury in an ATV accident that ended his senior season. A second doctor told him the tear would heal without surgery. He signed with Cal anyway, started as a freshman, and was named the 2023 Pac-12 Defensive Freshman of the Year. In 2025 he led the Bears with 100 tackles and made first-team All-ACC. After Cal’s staff was fired, he entered the transfer portal in January 2026 as 247Sports’ top portal linebacker, turned down bigger brands, and chose BYU so he could be home.

“You can’t take anything for granted. Nothing you do in life is guaranteed. You have to take advantage of every moment you’re given,” Uluave told the Salt Lake Tribune in an August feature about why he came back.

That is the pathway lesson. One school’s no is not the end of the story. Build film and a résumé somewhere that wants you. When the door opens again — through the portal, a walk-on spot, or a local program that finally sees you — you are ready.

The Defense That Closed It

Uluave was not alone. The Polynesian Football Hall of Fame’s 2026 college watch list includes several BYU defenders who showed up in the box score against Notre Dame: safety Raider Damuni with 7 tackles and 1 pass breakup, defensive tackle Keanu Tanuvasa with 2 tackles, and edge Tausili Akana with 2 tackles and 1 pass breakup.

Satuala, who stayed at BYU when his former defensive coordinator left for Michigan rather than enter the portal, told the Deseret News what the final call looked like from the secondary. “We went zero coverage and blitzed everybody and tried to force the quarterback to make a play and see whose dudes are better, and at the end of the day, we ended up winning,” he said. On the play before that incomplete pass in the end zone, CBS Sports’ play-by-play credits Satuala with the tackle on Micah Gilbert’s 6-yard catch that put Notre Dame at the BYU 8 with four seconds left.

Tanuvasa, speaking after the same stop, added: “We knew they were going to hard count. There is not much field, so, we got our hands up and try to deflect the ball. The DBs did great.”

Sitake framed the night in the AP recap the way a coach who has lived these finishes would: “We knew our offense could score and we knew they could get us in position to take the lead. We’ve been in these tight games before. It felt normal for us.”

A Walk-On Callback

One week after The Rock Report featured freshman running back Journee Tonga — the preferred walk-on who turned down scholarship offers to join BYU on an academic scholarship — Tonga was back in the rotation against Notre Dame. He finished with 3 carries for 6 yards and 1 catch for 12 yards, per the ESPN box score. It was not a starring night. It was another reminder that the walk-on path can still put a Polynesian freshman on the field in a top-10 showdown.

What Families Can Take From It

Uluave’s story and Satuala’s sit next to each other for a reason. One left Utah, became a star elsewhere, and came home through the portal. The other stayed when the portal opened and helped finish the biggest home win of the season. Both paths worked. Portal, walk-on and local commitment are all real routes — and none of them is automatic.

For Polynesian families helping a son navigate high school recruiting, the takeaway is practical. Keep developing when a dream school looks the other way. Choose a program that will put you on the field and coach you. Then, if the chance to come home or stay home appears later, you have earned it.

Around the Village

The same weekend carried the story onto NFL fields.

Nick Herbig, the Pittsburgh Steelers outside linebacker from Kauai and of Polynesian descent per Steelers.com, recorded 2 sacks — his first two of the season — plus 5 tackles and 3 tackles for loss in Pittsburgh’s 26-19 overtime win at Tampa Bay on Sunday, according to the Honolulu Star-Advertiser and Steelers.com.

Tetairoa McMillan, the Carolina Panthers wide receiver and 2024 Polynesian College Player of the Year, caught 6 passes for 86 yards on 9 targets in Carolina’s 25-14 win over the Philadelphia Eagles, per NBC Sports.

From Provo to Pittsburgh to Charlotte, the village kept showing up.

← Back to the Rock Report

Become a Sponsor

Want your logo here?

See partnership opportunities

Connect